Three Lawsuits in 12 Days: What Ohio's Attorney General Alleges Against Crown Pointe Remodeling, Journey Home Restoration and The Metal Roof Company
In twelve days this October, Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson's office filed three consumer-protection lawsuits against home-improvement contractors in three different counties. The companies are a Cincinnati remodeler, a Lorain County roofing and siding company with a high local profile, and a central Ohio metal-roofing installer. The complaints describe the same basic pattern: money paid up front for work that, the state alleges, was never finished or never started.
These are civil lawsuits. Each filing reflects the attorney general's allegations, and none had been decided by a court when they were announced. What follows is what the public record says, along with the parts of Ohio law the cases rely on, which apply to every contractor who takes a deposit in the state.
October 2: Hamilton County
The first filing came on October 2, 2026, in Hamilton County Common Pleas Court. According to the attorney general's release, the lawsuit alleges that Cincinnati-based Quincy Barrett and his company, Crown Pointe Remodeling, solicited consumers online and sold interior remodeling and repair work, along with roofing, siding, windows and other exterior work.
Consumers who complained to the attorney general's office say the defendants charged large upfront payments and didn't complete, or in some cases didn't start, the jobs. Nine consumers complained, citing damages of more than $100,000. The suit alleges three violations of Ohio's Consumer Sales Practices Act: shoddy and substandard work, failure to deliver goods and services, and failure to provide refunds.
The release adds a detail that explains why the owner is named personally. According to the lawsuit, Barrett personally endorsed some of the checks consumers wrote to Crown Pointe, and he had sole signatory authority over at least one company bank account.
"We will hold contractors accountable when they take consumers' money and run," Wilson said in the release.
October 14: Lorain County and Franklin County
Twelve days later, on October 14, the office announced two more lawsuits.
Journey Home Restoration (Lorain County). The state's lawsuit against Journey Home Restoration and its owner, Jason Kaczur, was filed in Lorain County Common Pleas Court. It alleges the company accepted $140,000 from nine customers for roofing, siding and gutter projects that were not completed, and it cites multiple violations of the Consumer Sales Practices Act. The release notes that Kaczur and the company "have maintained a high public profile in northeastern Ohio," including local TV appearances promoting the company's work and community involvement.
Cleveland's News 5 reported more of what the lawsuit alleges. In one case, the company began a roofing project and abandoned it before finishing. In another, it failed to honor a 10-year warranty after a roof leaked less than three years after installation. The suit also alleges that Journey Home Restoration is no longer in business or entering into home-improvement contracts. News 5 said the company did not respond to a phone call or email before publication.
Ericka Dilworth, vice president of operations at the Better Business Bureau serving Greater Cleveland, told News 5 that the company has an F rating with the BBB. She said complaints the business chose not to respond to began arriving "in about April of this year."
The Metal Roof Company (Franklin County). The second October 14 lawsuit, filed in Franklin County Common Pleas Court, names a central Ohio metal-roofing seller and installer and its owner. The release uses both "The Metal Roof Company" and "The Metal Roofing Company." It alleges the company performed substandard and defective roofing work for some consumers and didn't respond when they reported problems with their roofs. In one case, it allegedly accepted payment for a new roof and never began the project. Five consumers have reported combined losses of more than $60,000. Because the business appears to still be operating, the attorney general's office is asking other consumers with similar experiences to come forward.
Why the attorney general, and not a licensing board?
Contractors from other states often ask this first. The answer is in Ohio's licensing statute.
Ohio's statewide construction license is narrow. Under Ohio Revised Code 4740.01, the Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board licenses individuals as heating, ventilating and air conditioning, refrigeration, electrical, plumbing, or hydronics contractors, and the chapter's definition of "construction project" excludes residential buildings. Ohio has no statewide license for roofing, siding or general remodeling on homes. Registration for those trades, where it exists, is handled locally. In the attorney general's 2025 annual report, one earlier case alleged that the defendants failed to register as a contractor "in applicable jurisdictions," and another included a count for failing to obtain contractor registration. That's why the BBB's Dilworth told News 5 that homeowners should check with their municipality to make sure a contractor is approved to work there.
With no state board to discipline them, home-improvement disputes in Ohio usually end up under consumer-protection law. They also make up a large share of what the attorney general's office handles. Its 2025 Consumer Protection Annual Report says the office received 29,595 complaints that year, and home improvement ranked second, behind only motor vehicles.
The rules these cases lean on
The October filings cite the Consumer Sales Practices Act (R.C. Chapter 1345). Several rules under that law come up constantly in home-improvement cases, and every contractor who takes a deposit in Ohio should know them.
The failure-to-deliver rule. Ohio Administrative Code 109:4-3-09 makes it a deceptive act to accept money for goods or services and then let eight weeks pass without doing one of four things: delivering, giving a full refund, telling the consumer how long the delay will last and offering to refund within two weeks on request, or providing a substitute of equal or greater value that the consumer agrees to.
The estimates rule. OAC 109:4-3-05 covers repairs and services over $25. At first face-to-face contact, the contractor has to give the consumer a form that offers a written estimate, an oral estimate, or no estimate. If an estimate was requested and the job is over $50, the contractor needs the consumer's authorization before additional, unforeseen work that adds 10% or more to the estimate. The rule also bars charging for unauthorized work and requires an itemized list of the work performed.
The three-day cancellation window. Under the Home Solicitation Sales Act, R.C. 1345.22, a buyer in a home solicitation sale can cancel until midnight of the third business day after signing. When the sale requires services, the seller generally may not begin performance during that window.
What the attorney general can ask for. R.C. 1345.07 lets the attorney general seek declaratory judgments, injunctions, and orders to reimburse consumers. Courts can impose civil penalties of up to $5,000 per day for violating an injunction and, in qualifying cases, up to $25,000. The attorney general generally can't sue over a transaction more than two years after the violation.
How these cases can end
The new lawsuits are just starting. The attorney general's 2025 annual report shows how earlier ones ended. In one case listed there, a Cuyahoga County court entered a final judgment in July 2024. It ordered CLE Masonry LLC to pay $50,734.44 in consumer restitution plus a $25,000 civil penalty, and ordered Ohio City Contractors to pay $31,228 in restitution plus a $25,000 civil penalty, in a case brought under the Consumer Sales Practices Act and the Home Solicitation Sales Act. The report lists other cases that ended in default judgments, permanent injunctions, and restitution orders. It also lists contractor cases that were prosecuted as crimes.
Whether any of that happens in the October cases is for the courts in Hamilton, Lorain and Franklin counties to decide.
What honest contractors can take from this
None of these lawsuits concerns a technical code violation. They're about money, schedules, and communication. That gives contractors who run clean operations some practical guardrails:
- Match deposits to milestones. The Crown Pointe complaint centers on "large upfront payments." The more you collect before mobilizing, the more exposure you carry if the schedule slips.
- Use the eight-week rule as a calendar. If a job you've been paid for can't start within eight weeks, OAC 109:4-3-09 gives you lawful options: explain the delay and offer a refund, or agree on a substitute. Saying nothing isn't one of them.
- Put the estimate choice on paper. The 109:4-3-05 form costs nothing and settles arguments before they start.
- Respect the three-day window. Don't start work on a home-solicitation sale before the cancellation period ends.
- Honor the warranty you sold. One of the Journey Home allegations is a 10-year roof warranty that, the suit says, wasn't honored after less than three years.
- Answer the complaints. The BBB said the Journey Home complaints went unanswered. Wilson told News 5 that consumers often try to handle problems themselves first and get brushed off or given excuses by the company before they turn to his office.
The attorney general's office asks consumers who paid either company for work that wasn't performed, or who believe they received defective work, to contact it at OhioProtects.org or 800-282-0515.
IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.
Sources
- AG Wilson Sues Southwestern Ohio Contractor Accused of Incomplete Home Improvements (Ohio AG, Oct. 2, 2026)
- Wilson Sues 2 Home-Improvement Companies Accused of Taking Consumers' Money, Failing to Deliver (Ohio AG, Oct. 14, 2026)
- Ohio AG sues 2 home-improvement companies, including Lorain County business (News 5 Cleveland)
- Ohio AG Sues Home-Improvement Companies for Allegedly Scamming Customers (Insurance Journal, Oct. 16, 2026)
- Ohio Attorney General 2025 Consumer Protection Annual Report
- R.C. 4740.01 — Construction industry licensing board definitions
- R.C. 1345.07 — Attorney general actions
- R.C. 1345.22 — Right of buyer to cancel (Home Solicitation Sales Act)
- OAC 109:4-3-09 — Failure to deliver; substitution of goods or services
- OAC 109:4-3-05 — Repairs or services
Share this article
Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.
Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.
