A $90,000 Deposit, a Four-Day Trial, Two Felony Convictions: What the Naples, N.Y., Contractor Verdict Says About Handling Customer Money
On Friday, Oct. 16, 2026, after a four-day trial, a Schuyler County jury found a Finger Lakes contractor and his company guilty of stealing more than half of a customer's home improvement deposit.
According to the Schuyler County District Attorney's Office, as reported by WENY, Finger Lakes Daily News and FingerLakes1.com, the defendants are Joel S. Smith, 67, of Naples, N.Y., and his corporation, Naples Contracting Inc., also known as Diversified Contracting Co. Both were convicted of:
- second-degree grand larceny, a Class C felony, and
- first-degree falsifying business records, a Class E felony.
District Attorney Jeremy J. Hourihan tried the case himself. Sentencing is scheduled for Dec. 17. A jury verdict can still be appealed, and as of this writing no sentence has been imposed.
What the jury found
The facts, as described by the DA's office and reported by all three outlets, are simple:
- Smith and his company signed a home improvement contract with a customer.
- The customer paid a $90,000 deposit.
- The jury found that Smith took more than $50,000 of that money for his own purposes instead of using it on the job.
- The jury also found that Smith created false business records and gave them to the customer to justify the missing money and hide the theft.
Prosecutors didn't publicly name the customer or the property, and the coverage doesn't say what kind of project it was. We don't speculate here either.
The four steps above are the whole case. The money came in as a deposit, it wasn't used for the job, and records were made up to cover the gap. The last step is what the falsifying-business-records count covers. Here the cover-up was charged as a separate felony, on top of the larceny.
The licensing gap that isn't the story
Many people assume a contractor who handles $90,000 must hold a state license. In New York, that isn't so. The state Attorney General's office says home improvement contractors must be licensed in New York City and Suffolk, Nassau, Westchester, Putnam and Rockland counties. Outside those places, including much of the Finger Lakes, there is generally no state or county home improvement license to check.
A license wouldn't have changed what the jury found anyway. This case isn't about unlicensed work. It's about what happens to a customer's money between the day it's paid and the day it's spent. On that question, New York law is clear and applies statewide.
What New York law says about deposits
New York's home improvement contract law, General Business Law Article 36-A, applies to most residential improvements over $500, according to the AG. Combined with Lien Law § 71-a(4), it sets rules most homeowners, and plenty of contractors, have never read closely:
Payments before completion are trust money. Per the AG's fact sheet, money a contractor receives before a job is substantially complete must go into an escrow account at a bank in New York State within five business days. The customer must be told where it's held within ten business days. The contractor may withdraw it only:
- according to the payment schedule in the contract;
- at substantial completion; or
- if the customer breaches the contract, and then only enough to cover the contractor's reasonable costs.
A bond can take the place of escrow. Instead of an escrow account, the contractor may give the customer a bond, contract of indemnity or (per GBL § 771) an irrevocable letter of credit guaranteeing that the money will be properly used or returned. The AG says the bond must be delivered within ten business days after the money is received.
The contract has to say so. GBL § 771(1)(e) requires every covered contract to tell the owner that the contractor is "legally required to deposit all payments received prior to completion" under the Lien Law, or to post one of those guarantees instead. Section 771(1)(f) requires any progress-payment schedule to "bear a reasonable relationship" to the work done, materials bought or costs incurred at each stage. The contract must also include a three-business-day cancellation notice, start and completion dates, and a specific description of the work and materials.
There are penalties apart from any criminal case. The AG's fact sheet lists $100 civil fines for violating the home improvement contract law, fines of $250 to $2,500 for violating the provisions that protect customer payments, and a private right to sue for actual damages plus a $500 penalty and attorney's fees when fraudulent written statements were used to get a customer to sign.
Lessons for contractors
You don't have to be doing anything wrong to be hurt by a case like this. Every verdict like the one in Schuyler County makes the next homeowner more suspicious of a large deposit. The best defense is a paper trail that answers questions before anyone asks:
- Open a dedicated escrow account at a New York bank, or set up the bond or letter of credit, before you take your first deposit, not after.
- Put the depository's name in the contract. It's the simplest way to meet the disclosure requirement, and it shows the customer you know the rules.
- Tie every draw to a line in the payment schedule. For example, if the schedule ties a payment to rough-in, draw it at rough-in, with photos and an inspection record to back it up.
- Never let records lag the money. The felony in this case wasn't only the missing funds. It was paperwork that didn't match reality. Reconcile job accounts monthly and keep the bank statements.
- If a job stalls, say so in writing. A delay explained in writing is a scheduling problem. An unexplained delay with an empty escrow account can turn into a criminal case.
Lessons for anyone writing a large check
For homeowners and the property managers and facilities teams who hire residential contractors, the AG's advice comes down to a few questions to ask before paying a deposit:
- Is the contract in writing, with start and finish dates and a detailed scope?
- Does it name the bank holding my money, or include a bond?
- Does the payment schedule match the work, or am I paying far ahead of it?
- If I'm in New York City or Suffolk, Nassau, Westchester, Putnam or Rockland, is the contractor's local license active?
If the answer to any of these is no, the AG's guidance is blunt: look elsewhere.
The Naples case will return to court on Dec. 17. For everyone else, the lesson doesn't depend on the sentence: in New York, a deposit belongs to the customer until the work earns it.
This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.
IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.
Sources
- WENY, "Naples Contractor Convicted of Stealing from Customer's $90,000 Deposit" (Oct. 17, 2026)
- Finger Lakes Daily News, "Naples Contractor Guilty of Stealing Over $50K from Schuyler County Customer" (Oct. 17, 2026)
- FingerLakes1.com, "Naples contractor and company convicted of stealing over $50,000 from customer" (Oct. 17, 2026)
- New York Attorney General — Home Improvement Fact Sheet
- N.Y. General Business Law § 771 — Contract provisions (Justia)
- N.Y. Lien Law § 71-a (NYS Senate Open Legislation)
Share this article
Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.
Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.
