The Customer Paid You Everything but the $2,500 Deductible. In Texas, Here's How to Collect It Without Breaking the Law
This weekend, a contractor posted a familiar problem to Reddit's r/Contractor. The job was a $16,700 insurance repair, and it was finished. The homeowner had passed along every dollar the insurer paid. What was left was the $2,500 deductible, and the homeowner asked for more time. The contractor wondered about just writing it off. Hard Hat Report covered the thread on Nov. 1, noting that several states regulate that exact move.
The post didn't say where the job was. This piece walks through Texas, which has one of the broadest deductible laws on the books. If you work Texas storm or water claims, letting the deductible "slide" isn't a customer-service call. It can be a crime.
What Texas law says, in plain terms
Three short statutes do the work:
- The homeowner has to pay it. Texas Insurance Code § 707.002 says a person insured under a property policy "shall pay any deductible" on a first-party claim.
- The seller can't waive, absorb, rebate or "help avoid" it. Under Business & Commerce Code § 27.02(c), anyone selling goods or services paid from a property insurance claim commits an offense if, without the insurer's consent, they pay, waive, absorb or decline to collect the deductible, give a rebate or credit that offsets it, or "in any other manner" help the insured avoid paying it. That covers both advertising or promising it and actually doing it.
- It's a Class B misdemeanor. Under § 27.02(d) and Penal Code § 12.22, that means a fine of up to $2,000, up to 180 days in jail, or both.
The Texas Department of Insurance puts it bluntly: it's illegal for contractors to waive a deductible or help a homeowner avoid paying it, and contractors who do "could be fined or go to jail." TDI also names the common workaround, an estimate padded above the real cost so the insurer's money covers the deductible, and says that can amount to sending false information to the insurer.
Step 1: Don't write it off
Forgiving the $2,500 after the job is done is the textbook version of "waive" or "decline to collect." Agreeing to a smaller "credit" for the same amount falls under the rebate language. The only exception in the statute is the insurer's consent. If you think there's a real reason to adjust the number, the conversation is with the carrier, in writing, not a handshake with the homeowner.
Step 2: Check your contract for the required notice
If a contract is reasonably expected to be paid wholly or partly from a property insurance claim and the price is $1,000 or more, § 27.02(b) requires a specific notice in at least 12-point boldface type. The notice says Texas law requires the insured to pay the deductible and that it's a violation for the seller to knowingly let the insured skip it. Copy the statute's exact wording into your template. If your insurance-work contract doesn't have it, fix the template before the next job.
Step 3: Offer time, in writing, for the full amount
Here's the part the Reddit thread was hoping for: you can give the customer time. Insurance Code § 707.004 lets an insurer hold back recoverable depreciation, or a replacement-cost holdback, until it gets "reasonable proof" the deductible was paid. The statute lists what counts, and that includes "a copy of an executed installment plan contract or other financing arrangement that requires full payment of the deductible over time." TDI's consumer page says the same thing: a payment plan with your contractor is acceptable proof.
A clean installment agreement should:
- State the full deductible amount ($2,500 here), with no discount.
- Set a payment schedule with dates and amounts that add up to the full figure.
- Be signed by both sides and dated.
- Say what happens if a payment is missed (late fee, if any, and your right to pursue the balance).
- Be copied to the homeowner so they can send it to the carrier.
That last point helps you both. If the insurer is holding back depreciation until the deductible is proven, the signed plan can unlock that money for the homeowner, and that may be what funds your final payment.
Step 4: Keep the paper trail
Save the contract with the § 27.02 notice, every invoice, the insurer's payment records you received, the signed plan and each installment receipt. If anyone ever asks whether the deductible was really collected, the file answers.
Step 5: Know your lien dates, just in case
If the plan falls apart, Texas mechanic's lien deadlines are short. For an original contractor on a residential construction project, Property Code § 53.052(a)(2) requires the lien affidavit to be filed by the 15th day of the third month after the month the work was completed, terminated or abandoned. Liens on a homestead have extra contract requirements (see § 53.254), so talk to a construction attorney before you count on one. Put the date on your calendar the day the job finishes, even while the payment plan is running.
Step 6: Don't market around it
The offense also covers advertising or promising to cover a deductible. That includes yard signs, door hangers, social posts and anything a salesperson says. TDI separately warns Texas contractors not to act as, or advertise as, a public adjuster on jobs they're also doing (Insurance Code § 4102.163), per its roofing and insurance guidance. Train the sales team on both.
What the forum got right, and what it missed
Our take (commentary): most of the thread's instincts were decent. People wanted to be flexible with a customer who'd been straight with them. The miss was assuming "flexible" means "forgive." In Texas the flexible, legal answer is a written installment plan for the full deductible. It protects the contractor, it gives the homeowner breathing room, and it may even help release money the insurer is holding back.
Texas has no state roofing license (LicenseCheckHQ, 10/26/2026, noting HB 3344 didn't pass), so there's no state license board standing between a roofer and a deductible-waiver complaint. TDI tells consumers to report deductible offers to the Texas Attorney General's Consumer Protection Hotline, 800-621-0508.
This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.
IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.
Sources
- Hard Hat Report — "Customer won't pay the $2,500 deductible: why a contractor can't just let it slide" (Nov. 1, 2026)
- Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 27.02 — Goods or services paid for by insurance proceeds; payment of deductible required
- Tex. Ins. Code § 707.002 — Payment of deductible required
- Tex. Ins. Code § 707.004 — Reasonable proof of payment
- Tex. Penal Code § 12.22 — Class B misdemeanor
- Tex. Prop. Code § 53.052 — Filing of lien affidavit
- Texas Department of Insurance — Is it OK for a contractor to waive my deductible? (updated 12/9/2025)
- LicenseCheckHQ — Licensing news (10/26/2026): Texas roofers still don't need a state license after HB 3344 stalled
- Texas Department of Insurance — Roofing and insurance: Know the law (updated 3/24/2025)
Share this article
Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.
Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.
