The agency that doesn't sleep. Call (954) 860-7190 and ask Fiona, our AI assistant, anything, 24/7.

    M-F 9am-5pm EST
    From the Field
    National

    You Cracked the Customer's New Tub. Before You Reach for the Silicone, Know Who Pays: The Warranty Likely Won't, Your GL Policy Might Not, and a Real Repair Has Steps

    IQS Editorial Team
    November 13, 2026
    5 min read

    Correction, Nov. 13, 2026: An earlier version of this article misdescribed a Reddit post and suggested a tub the homeowner bought is more likely to be covered by the contractor's insurance. The policy sources we cite don't support that. Details are in the note at the end.

    On Nov. 10, Hard Hat Report wrote up a homeowner's account from Reddit's r/Plumbing: during a whole-house repipe, the plumber cracked a brand-new tub and offered to fill the crack with silicone. It's an argument that keeps resurfacing. In one r/Contractor thread, a homeowner says the crew that just installed a new tub wants to seal a crack instead of replacing it. In an r/Plumbing thread, another homeowner with a cracked new stone resin tub asks whether silicone can hold it until a replacement arrives.

    If you're the plumber or remodeler in that story, the answer isn't really about the crack. It's about who pays, and the answer is usually you. Here's how to handle it so you don't pay twice.

    Step 1: Don't put silicone in it

    Silicone stays soft. Anew Surface, a tub repair company in Newport, Kentucky, says flexible silicone or caulk shouldn't be used as a structural filler. It "remains pliable, allows continued movement, and prevents proper adhesion for any real repair attempted afterward." In other words, the bead you offer today can make the real fix harder next month.

    Step 2: Figure out whether it's a repair or a replacement

    Anew Surface draws the line this way. Repair is reasonable when the damage stays within the fiberglass or acrylic shell, the tub is otherwise sound, and the plumbing, subfloor and walls show no water damage or rot. Replacement is the better path when water has gotten into the subfloor or framing over time.

    A proper crack repair isn't a surface patch. Anew Surface describes removing weak or delaminated material, then drilling small stop holes at the crack ends to keep it from running. After that comes structural material to restore stiffness. Epoxyworks, the magazine of WEST SYSTEM epoxy maker Gougeon Brothers, describes grinding a bevel 12 times the laminate thickness on each side of a break. For a 1/8-inch laminate, that's a 1½-inch bevel. The bevel is then filled with layers of fiberglass cloth. With access from below, Epoxyworks says a plywood patch bonded with thickened epoxy can stiffen a cracked floor.

    Epoxyworks also explains why installers want to patch. Tubs usually go in before drywall, tile and flooring, so pulling one out is messy and expensive. Anew Surface says a full replacement commonly runs $10,000 to $14,000 in the Greater Cincinnati area once plumbing, tile and labor are factored in. Get that number for your own market before you offer anything.

    Step 3: Know the manufacturer won't pay

    American Standard's limited warranty for its Master Series tubs and acrylic bases excludes "defects or damage arising from shipping, installation, alterations, accidents" and more, "in all cases whether caused by a plumbing contractor, service company, the owner or any other person." It also won't pay for installation materials such as tile. Kohler's lifetime limited warranty on its plastic baths and receptors likewise says "damage caused by improper installation, alteration to the product, accident, negligence, misuse, or abuse is not covered." Under warranties like these, damage you cause during install is yours to fix, not the manufacturer's. Warranty terms quoted here are as of Nov. 13, 2026. Check the current warranty for the exact model.

    Step 4: Don't assume your general liability policy covers it

    This is the part that's easy to get wrong. Wexford Insurance explains that general liability is generally meant to cover accidental damage to someone else's property, not to fix the contractor's own work. "Your work" usually includes materials, parts or equipment you furnished. So if you supplied the tub, the policy may treat it as your work and decline to pay. As Wexford puts it, coverage depends on the policy language and the facts, and GL "is not intended to serve as a warranty or quality guarantee."

    Call your agent before you promise a fix, not after.

    Step 5: Paper it

    • Photograph the damage before anything goes on it, and keep the messages about it.
    • Put the proposed fix in writing: repair method, who does it, any warranty on the repair, and what happens if it fails.
    • Keep the receipt and model information. Manufacturers ask for proof of purchase on any claim. Wexford lists photos and project communications among the records that become valuable during claim investigations.

    The bottom line

    A cracked tub on your job is a business decision, not a caulk decision. Price a real structural repair against a full replacement. Check what your policy actually covers. Then give the customer a written choice. The contractor who handles it that way keeps the customer, and the one who offers silicone ends up as the next Reddit thread.

    Correction (Nov. 13, 2026): An earlier version said the homeowner's r/Plumbing post went up this week. We couldn't confirm when it was posted, and now describe it as Hard Hat Report's Nov. 10 write-up. We also removed our description of how the Reddit replies split (some saying seal it, others saying replace it), which we couldn't verify. We also now cite Kohler's warranty, Anew Surface's replacement-cost figure and Wexford Insurance's claim-records guidance directly instead of through Hard Hat's summary, and we removed a line saying a homeowner-bought tub is more likely to be covered, which the policy sources don't support.

    This article is for general information and isn't legal or insurance advice. Verify coverage with a licensed insurance professional and requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.

    Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.

    Follow International Qualifier Search for more: Facebook · LinkedIn · YouTube · Instagram

    Sources

    Share this article