A $93 "Clog Crusher," a Supreme Court Ruling on Phone Cancellations, and $700,000 in Restitution: Inside Pennsylvania's Six-Year Case Against Gillece
On Oct. 22, 2026, Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday announced a consent order with Gillece Services, LP, Gillece Plumbing and Heating, Inc., Thomas Gillece Sr., Thomas Gillece Jr. and two former Gillece technicians. It resolves a consumer-protection case his office first filed in Allegheny County more than six years ago. The defendants will pay $700,000 in consumer restitution and $50,000 in costs, with $250,000 in civil penalties suspended. The order was filed in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.
How the case got here matters as much as the dollar figure. Most of the attorney general's claims about sales tactics were never proven in court. They were settled, and the release states that the settlement "shall not be considered as an admission of violation of the law." One claim was decided, though, and appealed all the way to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. It changed how every home improvement contractor in the state has to handle a customer's phone call.
A $93 offer
According to the Tribune-Review's coverage of the complaint filed Sept. 1, 2020, Gillece is based in Bridgeville and served seven counties around Pittsburgh. It advertised a "Clog Crusher" special: the company would clear a sewer backup for $93, or the service would be free.
The attorney general's lawsuit alleged that once technicians arrived, many customers were told the clog couldn't be cleared with a snake and that only costly excavation would fix it. It alleged that work was often unnecessary, and that other plumbers later cleared some of the same lines with a conventional snake. The complaint also alleged the trucks carried only the most basic cutter, a "starting drill," and that technicians were often paid commission per job. It alleged scare tactics, too: customers were told they had gas leaks or cracked heat exchangers, diagnoses the attorney general says were later "discredited by third parties," including customers' gas utilities. The complaint noted 77 Better Business Bureau complaints since 2016, and said the office had sent the company a warning letter on Dec. 17, 2015.
Gillece fought back. In 2020 its attorney, John Linkosky, told the Tribune-Review the company "categorically denies every allegation." He said that since 2018 it had served 60,000 customers and held an A+ BBB rating. "Out of those, 77 people complained," he said. "You do the math."
The part a court actually decided
Partway through the case, the attorney general asked the court for partial summary judgment on narrower claims, and won. On Aug. 1, 2023, the Allegheny County court found that Gillece violated Section 7(b) of the Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act (HICPA), 73 P.S. § 517.7(b). The violation: refusing to honor customers' cancellations within three business days unless the cancellation was in writing. The attorney general's release says the court also ruled in the office's favor on false or misleading advertising, misrepresentations about flat-rate pricing, and penalizing customers who cancelled by entering their property without permission.
The appellate opinions describe the record behind the cancellation ruling. In one 2017 case, a homeowner called the dispatcher the evening he signed a sewer contract to say he wanted to cancel. The company logged the call, and a crew showed up the next morning anyway. In a 2018 case, crews dug a hole, the customer cancelled in writing within three business days, and the crew at first refused to leave without either refilling the hole or being paid for digging it. It left only after the customer called police. Gillece then sued that customer for unjust enrichment. In a third 2018 case, a customer phoned to cancel. A dispatcher then messaged the crew, in a note quoted in the Supreme Court's opinion, that she "MUST speak with [S]teve to cancel" and to "Just get there and begin the work PLEASE." The crew dug up her driveway while she was at work.
Gillece appealed. The Commonwealth Court affirmed on July 3, 2024. On April 30, 2026, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed again, in an opinion by Justice McCaffery (No. 32 WAP 2024).
Why every Pennsylvania contractor should read that ruling
Gillece's argument was technical, and many contractors probably assumed the same thing. Pennsylvania's general consumer law, the UTPCPL, lets buyers cancel door-to-door sales by "notifying, in writing, the seller." The standard cancellation notice says to mail or deliver a written notice. So doesn't a cancellation have to be in writing?
Not for home improvement contracts. The Supreme Court held that HICPA, which is more specific and was enacted 40 years later (2008 vs. 1968), governs. HICPA requires contractors to let a customer rescind within three business days, and it says nothing about writing. So contractors must honor "actual notice of cancellation" in any form, including a phone call or something said in person. The court also rejected Gillece's argument that it was impossible to comply. Handing out the standard written notice isn't a misrepresentation, the court said. But the written form is one way to cancel, not the only way.
The practical rule for any Pennsylvania home improvement contractor: if a customer tells your office, your dispatcher or your tech that they're cancelling within three business days, the job is cancelled. Log it, stop the crew and handle any refund the law requires.
What the consent order requires
Beyond the money, the consent order adds conduct terms on top of the 2023 injunction, which stays in force. According to the attorney general's release:
- Technicians who sell sewer excavation or hydro-jetting must be certified in NASSCO's Lateral Assessment Certification Program. Repair or replacement recommendations must rest on documented defects that meet NASSCO severity standards.
- If a line can't be opened, Gillece must make multiple attempts with a snake and tell the customer they can get a second opinion.
- HVAC technicians must be NATE-certified and use carbon monoxide meters calibrated on the manufacturer's schedule.
- A gas-leak diagnosis must generally be confirmed by the customer's gas utility before Gillece sells the repair. A cracked heat exchanger or other dangerous condition must be confirmed by two NATE-certified technicians.
- Gillece must give customers copies of contracts and cancellation notices at signing, must not advertise offers it won't honor, and must carve law enforcement out of any NDA.
- The two former technicians named as defendants are barred from the plumbing industry for five years.
Eligible customers will be contacted by the attorney general's office and don't need to do anything.
The takeaway
Most of the sales-practice allegations against Gillece were never adjudicated, and the company denied them from day one. What's left is a settlement and a Supreme Court rule that now binds everyone. For contractors, the lesson isn't really about one plumbing company in Allegheny County. Every home improvement contractor in Pennsylvania has to honor a phone call cancellation within three business days. And when a case like this ends in a settlement, the terms can include specific technician-certification requirements.
This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.
IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.
Sources
- Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General — AG Sunday Obtains Settlement Requiring Home Improvement Group to Pay Consumer Restitution… (Oct. 22, 2026)
- Supreme Court of Pennsylvania — OAG v. Gillece Services, L.P., No. 32 WAP 2024 (decided April 30, 2026), via Justia
- Commonwealth Court — Office of Attorney General v. Gillece Services, LP, No. 861 C.D. 2023 (July 3, 2024) (PDF)
- TribLive — State attorney general accuses Gillece Services of 'bait-and-switch' tactics on clogged sewer jobs (Sept. 2, 2020)
Share this article
Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.
Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.
