The agency that doesn't sleep. Call (954) 860-7190 and ask Fiona, our AI assistant, anything, 24/7.

    M-F 9am-5pm EST
    Business of Building
    Oregon

    "SFW Will Not Issue Any Form of Credit Without an NDA": Oregon Sues a Siding Contractor Over Alleged Review Gag Clauses

    IQS Editorial Team
    October 21, 2026
    9 min read

    Before a homeowner lets a contractor rip off rotted siding, they usually check the reviews. Oregon's attorney general says one contractor made sure those reviews couldn't tell the whole story.

    On Oct. 20, 2026, Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield sued SFW Construction LLC and Somerset Hills Construction LLC in federal court in Portland (State of Oregon ex rel. Rayfield v. SFW Construction LLC, No. 3:26-cv-02296). The state alleges that the companies, which it calls "SFW," buried a gag clause in their customer contract, used it to pressure unhappy customers into nondisclosure agreements and to take down reviews, and advertised a near-perfect rating without disclosing any of that.

    These are allegations. No court has ruled on them, and SFW hasn't had its say in court yet. We found no public response from SFW as of Oct. 21.

    The clause

    According to the complaint, SFW markets itself as a specialist in "exterior home repair, including siding repair and dry rot repair," in Oregon and Washington. Customers usually sign a "Service Agreement" through the e-signature platform PandaDoc. Below the signature is a hyperlink to an eight-page PDF of "mostly single-spaced boilerplate" called the Contract Specifications.

    Since at least 2022, the state says, that document has included an arbitration and mediation clause. It says any dispute "shall first be privately mediated," and that "[a]ny privately mediated settlement will include a non-disclosure agreement and a non-disparagement agreement." A second paragraph makes binding arbitration the exclusive method for disputes. It also says that by agreeing to it, "the parties . . . waive their right to file a complaint with the CCB," meaning Oregon's Construction Contractors Board.

    The state's theory is that the customer gives up the right to post a negative review at signing, before any dispute exists. The future NDA is agreed to before anyone knows whether the job will go well.

    How the state says the clause was used

    The complaint quotes SFW's own emails.

    • November 2023: "Unfortunately, my hands are tied regarding the credits coming with an NDA . . . . [I]t is in the contract as previously mentioned that all settlement agreements come with a non-disclosure agreement and a non-disparagement agreement. SFW will not issue any form of credit without an NDA."
    • February 2026: In settlement terms sent to a customer, the state alleges, SFW claimed the contract barred customers from complaining to the Better Business Bureau or the government. The complaint says this misrepresented what the contract actually says.
    • Removing reviews: The state alleges SFW "successfully demanded" that customers who wanted to settle remove reviews they had already posted.
    • "Hush money": When one customer resisted an NDA as "hush money," the state says SFW made two settlement offers that showed it valued the NDA at "nearly $3,000."

    According to the complaint, SFW called the NDA requirement a "company policy."

    What the website said

    The other half of the case concerns what prospective customers saw. The complaint quotes SFW's site as touting a "long and growing list of 5-star reviews from satisfied customers" and inviting visitors to "[j]oin hundreds of happy homeowners. 4.9/5 stars based on 500+ Google reviews." The state's position is that the rating is misleading because the site doesn't disclose the NDA policy, the clause against CCB complaints, or the requirement that settling customers delete negative reviews.

    The complaint is explicit about what the case is not about. In a footnote, it says the action "does not arise out of or relate to any particular consumer complaint or the quality of SFW's workmanship."

    The two counts

    Count 1 — Consumer Review Fairness Act (15 U.S.C. § 45b). The federal law, enacted in 2016, voids any provision of a form contract that "prohibits or restricts" a customer's ability to post a review. It also voids provisions that charge a penalty or fee for posting one. Subsection (c) makes it unlawful just to offer such a contract. State attorneys general may sue in federal court after notifying the Federal Trade Commission, and the complaint says Oregon did. The state argues that requiring, at signing, an NDA and non-disparagement term in any future settlement is a restriction on reviews.

    Count 2 — Oregon Unlawful Trade Practices Act (ORS 646.608(1)(e)). The state alleges the website's review claims gave SFW's services "characteristics" or "qualities" they don't have. It also alleges the violation was willful and that SFW didn't sign an assurance of voluntary compliance after receiving written notice.

    The state also says SFW didn't fully comply with a civil investigative demand dated May 12, 2026. According to the complaint, SFW produced the Contract Specifications and some communications from its outside counsel but "refused" the central request for its communications with consumers about reviews.

    What Oregon is asking for

    The prayer for relief asks the court to:

    • bar SFW from violating the CRFA and the UTPA
    • declare the review-restricting contract terms void
    • declare void the NDA and non-disparagement terms in settlements reached after SFW pointed to the contract
    • order SFW to tell those customers they aren't bound by the terms
    • award civil penalties, disgorgement, costs and attorney fees "to the extent authorized by applicable law"

    The state demanded a jury trial.

    "Reviews only mean something if customers are free to tell the truth, good or bad," Rayfield said in announcing the suit. He said the alleged conduct is "not fair to Oregon homeowners, and it's not fair to the honest contractors who earn their reputations the right way."

    What contractors should take from it

    Many contractors use boilerplate they haven't reread in years and settle disputes with confidentiality terms. Based on the statute, here's where the lines are:

    1. Form contracts can't restrict reviews. A standard contract a customer can't really negotiate can't prohibit or penalize honest reviews. Such a provision is void from the start, and offering it is a violation in itself. The law doesn't cover employer-employee or independent-contractor agreements.
    2. The CRFA leaves some protections in place. It doesn't affect defamation claims. It also keeps a business's right to remove certain content from its own website, such as personal information, abusive content, or content that is "clearly false or misleading."
    3. Settlements are where this case focuses. Oregon's argument is that a confidentiality term agreed to at signing, for any future dispute, operates as a review restriction. If your contract templates touch on reviews, confidentiality or "non-disparagement," have an attorney read them against this complaint.
    4. Don't misstate your own contract. Two of the state's allegations are about what SFW said its contract did: barring BBB and government complaints, and requiring NDAs. Describe your terms accurately.
    5. A rating is a representation. If you advertise a star rating, the UTPA claim here says what you leave out can matter as much as the number.

    Oregonians who believe a business used a form contract to stop them from posting an honest review can contact the Oregon DOJ at oregonconsumer.gov or 1-877-877-9392.

    This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.

    IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.

    Sources

    Share this article

    Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.

    Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.