New Jersey's ABC-Test Rules Are Now in Force: How to Check Whether Your 1099 Subs Would Hold Up Under N.J.A.C. 12:11
If you run a New Jersey crew, you've probably heard some version of this argument over the past month. One side says the state just changed the rules on independent contractors and every 1099 sub is now a W-2 employee. The other side says nothing changed at all. A "heads up" thread in r/newjersey warned the October 1 rules could upend freelance work as people know it. Business groups pushed for a delay. The state's labor chief called the opposition a "river of misinformation."
Here's the plain version: what took effect, what it says about the paperwork contractors rely on, and a five-step check for your own subs. The forum and political debate is paraphrased. Rule citations come from the New Jersey Department of Labor and Workforce Development (NJDOL).
What took effect, and what didn't
Status: ADOPTED and operative. Exemption bills in the Legislature are proposed, not law. NJDOL adopted N.J.A.C. 12:11 in May 2026 (the adoption notice is marked filed May 5, 2026), and it became operative October 1, 2026. They interpret the three-prong ABC test that has been in New Jersey's Unemployment Compensation Law since 1936. They apply across the Unemployment Compensation Law, the Wage and Hour Law, the Wage Payment Law and several related statutes.
The test itself didn't change. The business paying for the work must prove all three prongs:
- A. The worker has been and will continue to be free from control or direction over how the work is performed, both under the contract and in fact.
- B. The work is outside the usual course of the business, or it's performed outside all of the business's places of business.
- C. The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession or business.
Fail one prong and the worker is an employee.
Both camps have a point. Acting Labor Commissioner Kevin Jarvis told the New Jersey Monitor: "This is not a new test. This is not a change in enforcement." The New Jersey Business and Industry Association's Michelle Siekerka said the rules leave an "overly broad" interpretation in place. Senate President Nicholas Scutari had urged a delay to July 1, 2027, and Governor Mikie Sherrill has said she's open to specific carve-outs. Until a proposed exemption is enacted, the October 1 rules govern.
The five-step check
Step 1: Accept that the burden is yours
NJDOL is blunt: a 1099, a signed contractor agreement, or requiring the worker to form an LLC doesn't make someone an independent contractor. Once a worker is paid, the business has to prove all three prongs.
Step 2: Prong A — look at control in practice, not on paper
The adopted rule lists control factors that include whether you require specific tools, supplies or materials, require a uniform or logo, or require the worker to report at prescribed times or intervals. NJDOL's guidance also points to setting hours, giving training, and dictating the sequence of the work.
Two adoption changes matter: NJDOL dropped a proposed factor about company-controlled apps, and added that actions taken solely to comply with federal, state or local laws are not, standing alone, evidence of control.
Step 3: Prong B — the hardest prong for trade-on-trade work
If a drywall company subs out drywall, or a roofer subs out roofing, that work is very likely inside its usual course of business. Stevens & Lee's summary of the rule says a company's usual course of business includes any activities it regularly conducts. That leaves the other half of Prong B, work performed outside all of the business's places of business. The final rule's one specific location carve-out is a worker's personal residence used for remote work, which isn't counted as a place of business. How the rest of that alternative applies to jobsite work is a question for counsel. Be careful with drafts circulating online: the proposed rule included drywall-installer examples, but NJDOL removed those examples at adoption after business-community comments. The test still applies; the examples don't.
Step 4: Prong C — the paperwork contractors rely on isn't enough by itself
This is where the final rule speaks most directly to construction. Under N.J.A.C. 12:11-1.5 as adopted:
- Business registration (a sole proprietorship, LLC or corporation) is not alone sufficient. If you required or encouraged the worker to form an entity, that may suggest a "business in name only."
- The worker's own liability or workers' compensation insurance is not alone sufficient, and if you required or encouraged them to get it, it doesn't suggest independent-contractor status.
- Licensure in an occupation is not alone sufficient.
- Working for multiple employers doesn't, by itself, establish an independent business.
What does count, per NJDOL: their other customers and how much of their work you represent, their own employees, their own expenses, and their own tools and vehicles.
Step 5: Learn from the case the rules are built on
NJDOL says the rules synthesize decades of case law, including the New Jersey Supreme Court's unanimous 2022 decision in East Bay Drywall, LLC v. Department of Labor and Workforce Development, 251 N.J. 477. According to the Commissioner's findings, as quoted in the adoption notice, East Bay bid on, negotiated for and acquired all the work its "drywall subcontractors" performed. It set their pay as a fixed amount it didn't negotiate. It supplied the sheetrock, screws, corner bead and spackle, and it bore the risk of loss on each job. East Bay defended the arrangement with business registrations and insurance certificates. The Court found those documents didn't show independent businesses. Most of the insurance certificates covered only one year of the audit period, and nearly all the registrations had been revoked before the audit.
If your sub file is an LLC certificate and one year of COIs, it's thin.
What's at stake
According to NJDOL, misclassification penalties can include up to $250 per misclassified employee for a first violation and up to $1,000 for each subsequent violation, plus up to 5% of the worker's gross earnings over the prior 12 months payable to the worker. Where wage, benefit or tax violations are involved, the state can issue a stop-work order, suspend or revoke licenses the business needs to operate, and award liquidated damages of up to 200% of wages owed.
Enforcement is real. Per the New Jersey Monitor, state audits last year found about 14,000 misclassified workers and $1.3 billion in underreported wages, and the department has issued more than 200 misclassification stop-work orders since 2019, including orders this year to a masonry group and a builder.
The bottom line
The October 1 rules didn't create a new test. They wrote the existing one down, and the written version says an LLC, a COI or a license isn't enough on its own. Run the five steps on every 1099 sub, keep records that show real independence (other customers, their own crews and tools, invoices), and take any relationship that doesn't hold up to New Jersey employment counsel.
This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.
IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.
Sources
- N.J.A.C. 12:11 — Notice of Adoption, ABC Test; Independent Contractors (NJDOL, filed May 5, 2026; operative Oct. 1, 2026)
- NJDOL Adopts Clear Rules on Worker Classification (NJDOL press release, May 5, 2026)
- Independent Contractors and Misclassification (NJDOL My Work Rights)
- NJ labor chief criticizes 'river of misinformation' about independent contractor rule (New Jersey Monitor, Sept. 21, 2026)
- Controversial NJ independent contractor test regulations take effect (New Jersey Monitor, Oct. 1, 2026)
- New Jersey's Worker-Classification Regulations Take Effect: What Employers Need To Know (Stevens & Lee via JD Supra, Oct. 12, 2026)
- Heads up — new labor rules going into effect October 1st (r/newjersey discussion; paraphrased, no usernames quoted)
Share this article
Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.
Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.
