The agency that doesn't sleep. Call (954) 860-7190 and ask Fiona, our AI assistant, anything, 24/7.

    M-F 9am-5pm EST
    Business of Building

    Three Years After the Lahaina Fire, Maui Moves to Add a Full-Time Investigator for Contractor Fraud. Here's What the Public Record Shows

    IQS Editorial Team
    November 2, 2026
    9 min read

    On Aug. 8, 2023, wildfire destroyed most of Lahaina. Three years later, the rebuild is producing a second kind of loss. Survivors have reported paying contractors hundreds of thousands of dollars for homes that were never finished. On Friday, Oct. 23, 2026, the Maui County Council voted 8–0 on first reading to give the county prosecutor one more investigator whose full-time job will be contractor fraud tied to the fire (Maui Now, Oct. 27). The measure, Bill 147 (2026), comes back for second and final reading on Nov. 13.

    This report sets out what the public record and published reporting say. No contractor has been charged in connection with post-fire work, as far as the reporting we reviewed shows. Every allegation below is attributed to the person or document that made it.

    What the council approved

    Bill 147 was introduced by Council Chair Alice Lee at Mayor Richard Bissen's request. According to Maui Now:

    • It raises the Department of the Prosecuting Attorney's staffing from 85.6 to 86.6 equivalent positions by amending the fiscal 2027 budget. It takes effect on approval.
    • It adds no new money this fiscal year. An Oct. 15 letter from Budget Director Lesley Milner said no added funds were needed. Prosecuting Attorney Andrew Martin told the council the salary would come from cost savings.
    • The new hire would be an Investigator III, the seventh in the office's investigative services division. Council Member Tamara Paltin said the position is SR-20, and county pay data put the range at $61,284 to $87,336 a year.
    • Milner's letter cites the "unforeseen scope and complexity" of investigating possible fraud related to the 2023 fires, including financial and contract records, interviews with victims and witnesses, and preparing cases for possible prosecution.

    Martin told the council his office started referring contractor-fraud tips to the Maui Police Department in May 2025, then opened its own investigation to move faster, and is "now moving on to a second one." Search warrants and subpoenas are producing "voluminous" financial records, he said. One deputy prosecutor has worked almost exclusively on the cases this year. A newly hired deputy, a former assistant U.S. attorney with complex white-collar experience, starts Nov. 6 and will join the effort full time (Inside Climate News/Civil Beat, Oct. 30).

    Why it took a newspaper investigation

    The bill followed a joint investigation by Honolulu Civil Beat and Inside Climate News, published Sept. 2, 2026 (Inside Climate News). The two newsrooms reviewed hundreds of pages of police reports, court filings, contracts and texts. Their key findings:

    • Dozens of survivors had reported serious problems to local and state officials. Contractors stopped showing up, couldn't account for large payments, or did work so poorly it had to be redone.
    • At that point, government agencies had announced no actions against contractors for post-fire misconduct: "no criminal charges, no licenses revoked, no fines or injunctions."
    • In response to a records request, the Maui Police Department released 10 reports describing losses from about $20,000 to more than $500,000. All were marked as civil matters, not police matters.
    • The state Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs (DCCA) said it was aware of 12 complaints connected to post-fire rebuilding. Eight were still under investigation, and the rest had closed without discipline. The newsrooms found 14 more complaints in DCCA's online database against contractors that homeowners and advocates named as repeat problems, all pending.

    The survivors' accounts in that reporting are hard to read. Raquel Utrillo told the newsrooms she paid a contractor $640,000, according to documents she shared, to prepare her family's Lahainaluna lot and install a prefabricated home. She said he stopped showing up shortly after starting and stopped answering by early 2026. The reporters said he does not hold the required state license and that they could not reach him. Krista Woodward said she paid $650,000 to an unlicensed contractor to manage her Wahikuli rebuild and that he couldn't account for nearly $500,000 of it. That contractor died in May 2026, and DCCA closed its investigation soon after. Waterman Archie Kalepa and his wife, Alicia, have a lawsuit pending against an unlicensed contractor and his partner. They allege more than $200,000 in losses. The defendants' lawyer wrote in court filings that his clients "categorically deny" the allegations and contest liability.

    Some of the complaints involve licensed contractors too. One licensed contractor named in DCCA complaints told the newsrooms that most were from clients frustrated by shipping delays and material shortages, and that he shouldn't be grouped with unlicensed operators.

    The bar for a criminal case

    Martin explained why prosecutions are slow. In Hawaii, he said, prosecutors must prove a builder took payment for work they never intended to finish. Otherwise the dispute belongs in civil court. "It's a high bar," he told the newsrooms, and what his office looks for is patterns across multiple properties. At the council meeting he called the cases "complex and involved" because of the need to separate civil complaints from criminal ones.

    The comparison the reporting drew is with Los Angeles after the January 2025 fires. There, Deputy District Attorney Ryann Gerber Jorban proposed a contractor-fraud working group within a week. Working with California's Contractors State License Board, the office began planning undercover stings within two months, and those produced 14 cases involving 15 contractors, now pretrial.

    What Hawaii law already provides, and what it doesn't

    Hawaii's contractor statute, HRS Chapter 444, gives homeowners and regulators real tools, but they have limits that matter here.

    • Unlicensed contracting fines are large on paper. Under HRS § 444-23(c), a person who contracts without the required license (§ 444-9) faces a fine of $2,500 or 40% of the total contract price, whichever is greater, for a first offense. That rises to $3,500 or 40% for a second and $5,000 or 40% for later ones. Tools and materials can be forfeited in some cases.
    • An unlicensed contractor can't sue to get paid. HRS § 444-22 bars recovery for work by anyone who wasn't licensed when they contracted. Hawaii's courts have held that a homeowner can still sue the unlicensed contractor for breach.
    • Licensed contractors owe homeowners specific disclosures. HRS § 444-25.5 requires a signed written contract before work starts. The contractor must explain lien rights and the owner's option to demand bonding. A violation is an unfair or deceptive practice under chapter 480.
    • The recovery fund is small, and only for licensed work. At the Oct. 23 meeting, Council Member Tom Cook, who said he worked as a contractor for 35 years, described the state's Contractors Recovery Fund as paying up to $10,000. The statute, HRS § 444-26, actually sets the cap at $12,500 per contract, by court order. The bigger limit is who can claim: the fund covers homeowners injured by a duly licensed contractor. It doesn't pay when the contractor's license was suspended, revoked, forfeited, terminated or inactive when the contract was signed. Measured against losses of $200,000 to $640,000 reported by survivors, that's not much, and for families who hired unlicensed builders it's nothing. Asked whether the cap should go up, Martin said that's a state matter but "if it can be increased, it should."

    What happens next

    • Nov. 6: the new deputy prosecutor starts full time on the cases, per Martin.
    • Nov. 13: Bill 147 second and final reading.
    • 2027 session: Sen. Angus McKelvey, who represents Lahaina and lost his home in the fire, told the newsrooms he plans legislation to push DCCA to act faster on predatory or negligent contractors.

    Martin and Mayor Bissen have both said more survivors came forward after the September reporting and an Aug. 12 community meeting. "This was an underreported crime at one time," Bissen told Civil Beat, in the story Inside Climate News republished.

    What the record tells every contractor

    Our read (commentary): the Lahaina record shows how post-disaster demand breaks the usual checks. Homeowners on insurance deadlines hire whoever is available, often by word of mouth. In at least one case described in the Kalepa lawsuit, a license number provided belonged to a different contractor, who said he never authorized its use. These are allegations, not findings. But the takeaway for legitimate builders is practical: put your license number on every contract, give the § 444-25.5 disclosures every time, and expect homeowners and prosecutors to check. After a disaster, the paperwork is what separates your business from the people the investigators are looking for.

    Survivors who were told their report was a "civil matter" can contact the Maui County Department of the Prosecuting Attorney directly, as Martin urged in the reporting. Complaints about licensed or unlicensed contractors go to DCCA's Regulated Industries Complaints Office.

    This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.

    IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.

    Sources

    Share this article

    Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.

    Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.