The Excavator Warned About Groundwater in Writing, Billed by the Hour and Blew Up the GC's Budget. How to Price, Cap and Give Notice on Wet Ground Before It Happens to You
Over the weekend on Reddit's r/Construction, the owner of a 10-year-old excavation company laid out a problem a lot of subs will recognize. According to the post, as summarized by Hard Hat Report on Nov. 8, he agreed to dig on a municipal job for an out-of-town plumbing contractor only at hourly rates. He warned in writing about groundwater and called his $18,000 to $22,000 estimate a guess. He says he proposed a design change and waiting for dry weather, and nobody listened. Now his hours are running far past the general contractor's budget, and he's asking whether he should do anything about it.
The thread is a good argument about who carries wet-ground risk. Here's how to keep yourself out of either seat.
1. Know what "hourly" means on paper
A time-and-materials deal without a ceiling bills the labor and materials actually used. The party paying the hours carries the overrun. A not-to-exceed (NTE) clause is what moves risk back to the contractor. Once billings hit the cap, the contractor absorbs the rest unless a change order is signed first. Per the post, this job had no cap.
If you're the sub: you can offer an NTE, but put the assumptions next to it, such as "dry conditions, no dewatering, no unsuitable soils." That way the cap applies to the job you priced, not every job the ground turns it into.
If you're the GC: never carry a fixed number in your prime contract over a sub's uncapped hourly work without a site-conditions clause behind you.
2. The GC's clock is in the prime contract
The general contractor's real exposure sits upstream. Under AIA A201 § 3.7.4 (Concealed or Unknown Conditions), a contractor that hits subsurface conditions materially different from the contract documents must notify the owner and architect before disturbing them, and no later than 14 days after first seeing them. AIA's own guidance says the analysis starts with the drawings, specs, geotech reports and borings. A bidder's private assumption, standing alone, isn't a contract indication.
On federal jobs, FAR 52.236-2 says the same thing more bluntly. Written notice must go to the contracting officer "promptly, and before the conditions are disturbed." No adjustment is allowed without it, and none after final payment. Municipal contracts usually carry their own version, so read yours.
3. A Texas case shows what notice is worth
Courts have sorted this out before. In City of Fort Worth v. Gene Hill Equipment Co. (Tex. App.–Fort Worth, Nov. 17, 1988), the contractor dug for underground fuel tanks at the city's Citran facility on an $84,100 contract. It hit rock, subsurface water and unstable soil. The contract said the price assumed "normal" excavation and that the city was to be notified of abnormal conditions.
The appeals court let Gene Hill keep its money for the rock, because the city's engineer testified he was told about it and allowed the work. But it cut $3,425.81 for the retaining wall and water removal, because the record showed no evidence the engineer was told about the water and soil first. The court also gave the city $950 in liquidated damages for 19 late days. Same job, same ground: the work with notice got paid, and the work without notice didn't.
4. A field routine for wet ground
Adapted from AIA's differing-site-conditions checklist:
- Stop and protect the affected area when it's safe and the contract allows. Keep working on unaffected scope.
- Send formal notice through the channel the contract names: location, date, what you found, what the documents showed, and the likely cost and time impact. A daily report or a hallway conversation isn't notice.
- Document before it changes, with date-stamped photos and video, water levels against a fixed reference, weather, and crew and equipment on site.
- Open a separate cost code for dewatering, standby, shoring and rework so the extra can be tested on its own.
- Send weekly hour reports to whoever is paying. That way, nobody can call the overrun a surprise.
The takeaway from the thread
The excavator's written warning protected his reputation. It didn't change his contract. If you price wet ground by the hour, put the warning, the rate, any cap and a reporting schedule in the signed paper. If you're the GC holding a fixed price over that sub, your notice deadline under the prime contract started the day the water showed up.
This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.
IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.
Sources
- Hard Hat Report — Excavator warned in writing about groundwater, billed by the hour, and is now blowing up the GC's budget (Nov. 8, 2026)
- AIA Contract Documents — What Are Differing Site Conditions in Construction? (A201 § 3.7.4)
- Acquisition.gov — FAR 52.236-2 Differing Site Conditions
- City of Fort Worth v. Gene Hill Equipment Co. (Tex. App.–Fort Worth, Nov. 17, 1988) (CourtListener)
Share this article
Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.
Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.
