The agency that doesn't sleep. Call (954) 860-7190 and ask Fiona, our AI assistant, anything, 24/7.

    M-F 9am-5pm EST
    Business of Building

    A "Free Inspection" Form That Was Really a Contract: Delaware's Case Against Mastercraft Contracting, and the Home-Improvement Rules Behind It

    IQS Editorial Team
    October 29, 2026
    12 min read

    All allegations in this article come from the Delaware Department of Justice's public filings and press releases. They haven't been proven. The respondents are entitled to a hearing, and an administrative hearing officer will decide liability.

    The pitch, as Delaware's Department of Justice describes it, started at the front door. A salesperson offered a free roof inspection and said the homeowner needed to sign a form to authorize it. According to the state, that form was a contract. If the homeowner later decided not to hire the company, the contract claimed liquidated damages equal to one-third of the contract price. The state alleges the company then pursued that money with threats of liens and with lawsuits, often when it had done little or no work.

    On Oct. 27, 2026, Attorney General Kathy Jennings announced that the DOJ's Consumer Protection Unit (CPU) had filed an administrative complaint against Mastercraft Contracting, LLC and its principals, Majid Sefiane (also known as Michael Strong) and David Caprario. The complaint document posted by the DOJ is dated Oct. 20 in its file name. (The state's web server blocked our attempts to open it, so this article relies on the DOJ's press releases and published news coverage.)

    How the case got here

    This case didn't start this week. The public record shows a long effort to get documents out of the company.

    • 2025: According to the DOJ, Delaware Superior Court ordered Mastercraft to respond to a CPU subpoena.
    • Early 2026: After reviewing those documents, the CPU sent a second subpoena for the "next phase" of its investigation.
    • May 11, 2026: The DOJ asked Superior Court to enforce that second subpoena, saying Mastercraft had failed to respond substantively for nearly three months. The release described the company as a home improvement contractor with multiple consumer complaints, and said the complaints alleged it targets homeowners who recently experienced significant storms with door-to-door sales of roofing and construction services. Delaware Business Now identified the company as based in Dover.
    • Oct. 27, 2026: The CPU announced the administrative complaint.

    What the state alleges

    According to the Oct. 27 announcement and the CoastTV report on it, the complaint alleges that Mastercraft:

    1. used misleading door-to-door sales tactics to persuade homeowners that they had to sign a form to get a "free" inspection;
    2. presented binding contracts as inspection forms. The contracts carried what the state calls punitive cancellation penalties, which locked consumers into services they didn't want;
    3. threatened liens and lawsuits to enforce those terms, often when it had performed little or no work; and
    4. used the Better Business Bureau logo and claimed "accreditation" without being BBB-accredited.

    The May release added a detail: the company filed lawsuits against consumers in Delaware's Justice of the Peace Court to collect the one-third liquidated damages. The DOJ says Delaware courts have dismissed several of Mastercraft's lawsuits and found that the liquidated damages clause was an unenforceable penalty.

    The CPU alleges violations of four sets of rules: the Consumer Fraud Act, the Deceptive Trade Practices Act, the Home Solicitation Sales Act and Delaware's Home Improvement Regulations. It's seeking civil penalties, restitution, and orders stopping Mastercraft and its principals from continuing the alleged practices.

    "Contractors shouldn't turn that vulnerability into a sales trap, weaponize fine print, or bully Delawareans with frivolous lawsuits," Jennings said in the release.

    We found no public response from Mastercraft or its principals in the coverage we reviewed.

    The rules at the center of the case

    Legitimate contractors should read this part closely. The practices alleged here line up with specific prohibitions that every home improvement contractor in Delaware has to follow.

    The Home Improvement Regulations (in effect since Nov. 1, 2023)

    The CPU adopted these rules under the Consumer Fraud Act. They took effect Nov. 1, 2023, after a public hearing on May 24, 2023. The DOJ said at the time that it got about 80 home improvement complaints in 2021, about 200 in 2022 and about 120 in the first seven months of 2023. The regulation, 6 DE Admin. Code 106, makes it an unlawful practice to, among other things:

    • include a liquidated damages clause that gives the contractor the same amount no matter how much work was done (§ 3.1.12);
    • misrepresent whether a contract is binding, "such as by representing that a home improvement contract is an estimate" (§ 3.1.13);
    • structure a contract so the buyer has to sign before the contractor is bound (§ 3.1.4);
    • leave final terms blank when the buyer signs (§ 3.1.3);
    • fail to give the buyer the CPU's summary of the regulations before the buyer signs (§ 3.1.11); and
    • falsely tell a buyer that existing equipment or property is dangerous, defective, or in need of repair or replacement (§ 3.1.26).

    The rules cover alterations, repairs and improvements to a dwelling or the property it sits on, roofs and gutters included. They don't cover new construction of single-family homes.

    The Home Solicitation Sales Act (door-to-door sales)

    For a door-to-door sale of $25 or more, 6 Del. C. ch. 44 requires the seller to:

    • give the buyer a completed copy of the contract at signing, with a bold notice that the buyer may cancel before midnight of the third business day;
    • attach a "Notice of Cancellation" form in duplicate, and tell the buyer orally about the right to cancel;
    • leave out any waiver of the right to cancel; and
    • refund payments within 10 business days of a valid cancellation (§ 4404).

    Two more sections apply to salespeople at the door. Under § 4405, a salesperson must display a door-to-door salesperson identification card issued by the Department of Finance. Under § 4406, door-to-door soliciting at homes is allowed only between 9 a.m. and 8 p.m. Violating either section carries a fine of $75 to $150 for a first offense and $100 to $250 after that.

    What the state can win

    Delaware law sets the possible penalties for violations like these:

    • Administrative case (this one): for a willful violation, the hearing officer must order a civil penalty of up to $5,000 per violation, and may issue a cease-and-desist order (29 Del. C. §§ 2523–2525). Either side can appeal the final order to Superior Court within 30 days.
    • Court case: in a court proceeding, the penalty for a willful violation is up to $10,000 per violation (§ 2522(b)), along with possible restitution, rescission and asset freezes (§ 2522(c)).
    • Violating an order: willfully violating a cease-and-desist order or injunction carries an enhanced penalty of up to $25,000 per violation (§ 2526).

    What legitimate contractors should take from it

    Delaware doesn't give a statewide general contractor exam. Any contractor doing business in Delaware has to register with the Division of Revenue and get a business license. Nonresident contractors also have bonding requirements. So Delaware relies heavily on consumer-protection law to police home improvement work, and this case shows where the CPU is focusing.

    If you sell roofing or exterior work in Delaware, or anywhere, here's a fine-print check worth doing this week:

    1. Keep inspection authorizations separate from contracts. If a form only authorizes an inspection, it shouldn't contain a price, a cancellation penalty or a damages clause. If it's a contract, it has to say so.
    2. Make cancellation charges match the work. A flat percentage that applies whether you've done nothing or everything is what § 3.1.12 prohibits.
    3. Hand over the CPU summary and the cancellation forms every time. Both are required, and both are easy to show you provided.
    4. Equip door-knockers properly. Make sure every canvasser carries a valid ID card and knocks only between 9 and 8.
    5. Don't claim affiliations you don't have. The state's complaint makes an issue of BBB logos and "accreditation."
    6. Think before you sue a customer. If the clause you're enforcing is one a court may call a penalty, the lawsuit can become evidence against you.

    Homeowners who think they were misled can file a complaint through the Delaware DOJ's complaint portal.

    This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.

    IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.

    Sources

    Share this article

    Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.

    Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.