The agency that doesn't sleep. Call (954) 860-7190 and ask Fiona, our AI assistant, anything, 24/7.

    M-F 9am-5pm EST
    From the Field

    The Customer Is Holding Back the Last $12,000. What California Law Says About Change Orders, Credits and Your Lien Clock

    IQS Editorial Team
    October 29, 2026
    10 min read

    Contractor forums had a theme this week: the job is nearly done, and the customer suddenly wants money back.

    One of this week's top posts on r/Contractor came from a California general contractor, a carpenter for 15 years before he started his own company three years ago. His story, in short: he signed a fixed-price contract to pull and reinstall four windows during dry-rot repairs. The homeowner then switched to new windows. After those were ordered, the homeowner mentioned custom interior shutters. The GC warned that extra casing might be needed and would be a change order, and the homeowner agreed. Now the homeowner wants the casing for free. He also wants a credit because the drywall removal the contract covered "as needed" turned out not to be needed. He has questioned the price because five workers did most of the job in two days, and he asked the crew what they're paid. About $12,000 is still owed. The GC paused the last day of trim and asked the forum whether he should file a lien.

    He wasn't the only one. On r/GeneralContractor, a contractor described a customer demanding a discount because a sliding door was installed with its fixed panel on the side the customer didn't want, even though the contract didn't say which side. Another r/Contractor thread this week was titled, roughly, "they decided to reduce the contract by $300 at project end." On X, a construction attorney posted on Oct. 27 that the most expensive change order is the one you never documented.

    The replies split the usual way. Some said finish, invoice and lien. Others said give a little and move on. Here's what California law actually says, using the window job as the example.

    1. A change order counts only if it's signed before the work

    California's home improvement statute, Business and Professions Code § 7159, is blunt on this. A change-order form has to be built into the contract, and a change order becomes part of the contract only if it's in writing and signed by the parties before the work it covers starts (§ 7159(c)(5) and (d)). Every home improvement contract must also include a "Note About Extra Work and Change Orders." That note says the order has to describe the extra work, the amount added or subtracted, and the effect on the progress-payment schedule (§ 7159(d)(13)).

    The buyer's side of the rule is in § 7159(e)(3): a buyer can't require extra work without written authorization, and a change order isn't enforceable against the buyer unless its scope, price and schedule effect were put in writing first.

    The same paragraph also offers a fallback. A contractor's failure to follow these rules "does not preclude the recovery of compensation for work performed" under legal or equitable remedies meant to prevent unjust enrichment (§ 7159(e)(3)(C)). A verbal "yes" to the casing doesn't make an enforceable change order. It may still support a claim for the value of the work, but that's a harder fight.

    For the window job: if there's no signed change order for the casing, the clean move is to write one now, before installing it. List the scope, the price and the effect on the final payment, and get it signed. If the customer won't sign, you're deciding whether to do unsigned extra work.

    2. The "unused drywall" credit depends on your contract's wording

    Whether "drywall and stucco removal/repair as needed" means a price for the risk or an allowance to be credited back depends on how the contract was written. The statute doesn't settle it. Next time, if a line item is contingent, say so in plain words: either "included in the fixed price whether or not required," or "allowance of $X, credited if unused." The change-order note required by § 7159(d)(13) already says an order must state the cost "to be added or subtracted." A credit is just a change order going the other way.

    3. Pausing the last day of work also pauses your lien rights

    This is the point most commenters missed. Under Civil Code § 8412, a direct contractor can enforce a mechanics lien only if it records the claim after completing its direct contract, and before the earlier of:

    • 90 days after completion of the work of improvement, or
    • 60 days after the owner records a notice of completion or cessation.

    So a contractor who stops one day short of finishing isn't in a position to record a lien yet. Under Civil Code § 8180, completion includes actual completion, occupation or use by the owner plus cessation of labor, 60 straight days of no labor, or a recorded notice of cessation after 30 days of no labor. Recording the lien doesn't end the job, either. Under Civil Code § 8460, you have to file suit to enforce it within 90 days of recording, or the lien expires.

    4. Don't bill ahead of the work, even to make a point

    Under B&P § 7159.5(a)(5), apart from the down payment, a contractor can't request or accept payment that exceeds the value of the work performed or materials delivered. Violating that paragraph is a misdemeanor, with a fine of $100 to $5,000, up to a year in county jail, or both (§ 7159.5(b)(1)). Bill for what's done, finish, then bill the balance.

    5. Know your small claims and CSLB options

    • Small claims: the general limit is $6,250 (Code Civ. Proc. § 116.220). Actions brought by a natural person can go up to $12,500 (§ 116.221). If your company is an LLC or corporation, a $12,000 claim is over the general limit.
    • CSLB arbitration: under B&P § 7085, after investigating a complaint arising from a home improvement contract, the registrar can refer the dispute to arbitration when both sides agree and other criteria are met. For a larger claim, "material damages" means above the contractor bond amount and below $50,000.

    6. What the crew earns isn't part of the contract

    A fixed-price contract is a price for the result. Section 7159.5 requires the contract amount to include "the entire cost of the contract, including profit, labor, and materials." Nothing in the statute ties a fixed price to hours or wages. Politely decline that line of questions.

    The veteran's take (commentary)

    Most of these fights start with something that was agreed out loud and never written down. Make it a rule that nothing new happens on site until there's a signed change order, even for $150 of casing. Price contingent items in plain words, finish the work before you threaten a lien, and save the forum post for after you've been paid.

    This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.

    IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.

    Sources

    Share this article

    Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.

    Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.