$8 Million Owed and a $30,000 Cap: What Holtzman Construction's Chapter 7 Collapse in Arizona Shows About Deposits, Subs and the Recovery Fund
On Monday morning, Nov. 9, 2026, Brandon Scott Holtzman was sworn in at a Chapter 7 bankruptcy hearing. Customers he'd taken deposits from listened in on Zoom. Holtzman co-owns, with Danny Holtzman, the four Tempe-based companies that filed for bankruptcy on Oct. 2: Holtzman Construction LLC, Holtzman Remodeling LLC, Holtzman Holdings LLC and Holtzman Staffing LLC. The companies' bankruptcy lawyer has said customers, suppliers and other creditors are owed about $8 million.
What follows is drawn from the testimony as reported by FOX 10 Phoenix, earlier reporting by FOX 10 and Arizona's Family, and Arizona statutes. No court has found wrongdoing by the Holtzmans or their companies. No criminal charges have been reported. Customers' accounts below are their allegations as reported.
How it unraveled
FOX 10's first report ran Sept. 29. Richard and Amanda Finley said they signed with Holtzman Construction in August 2024 for a $900,000 project on their home. Work started in January 2026, went well for about three months, then mostly stopped. "Holtzman has taken $622,000 out of a $900,000 project," Richard Finley told the station. He estimated about $135,000 of work had been done.
The same report quoted Eric McClay and Sarah Amato, owners of A&M Electric, a subcontractor on several Holtzman jobs. They said they were owed $36,657 across about 12 jobs. FOX 10 also cited Registrar of Contractors (ROC) data: more than 150 complaints filed against Holtzman companies since 2010, and 45 since 2024 against Holtzman Construction.
On Sept. 30, FOX 10 reported that Kate Thongtrangan had paid more than $400,000 on a $680,000 contract for a medical consultation office. She said the project was less than a third done. A Sept. 16 email to her from Brandon Holtzman cited a "major, unexpected challenge." The station said the ROC website showed the licenses for Holtzman Construction and Holtzman Remodeling as voluntarily canceled. It also tied Brandon Holtzman to a newly formed Haul Pros LLC.
On Oct. 1, Holtzman issued a statement: "We had a unique and unexpected challenge to our business." He apologized to customers, subcontractors and employees.
On Oct. 6, Arizona's Family reported that Johnnie Coletto had paid deposits of more than $48,000 and more than $4,500 for a kitchen and bath remodel. She said the company took $122,000 from her in total before telling her it couldn't finish. The companies' bankruptcy attorney, Joel Sannes, told the station he saw "a fundamental business flaw that had to do with how the sales worked." Salespeople were paid on commission, he said, with "too little oversight" of whether their bids were profitable. In his view, customer deposits "went towards other people's construction projects."
What Holtzman said under oath
At the Nov. 9 hearing, questions came from Chapter 7 panel trustee Eric Haley, bankruptcy attorney Philip Rudd, and customers and subcontractors on Zoom. According to FOX 10:
- He blamed two employees. Holtzman said one salesperson sold large projects at prices that weren't profitable to earn a commission, and the operations manager let those bids through the company's system as profitable. He testified that neither was an owner or manager. He also said he built that system himself, and it wasn't commercially available.
- The timeline of insolvency. Leadership learned about two weeks before the Oct. 2 filing that the companies couldn't pay their debts, he testified. After that they took no money for new projects but kept accepting progress payments on ongoing jobs.
- No internal review. Asked whether there had been any investigation into misuse of funds, he said none had been done internally. He said company vehicles and property were at a location the bankruptcy auctioneer knows about.
- Stepping away. He said he'd left the company temporarily in May 2025 because he "needed a break."
- Other companies. Asked whether he runs construction companies anywhere else, he said no. FOX 10 reported that a Brandon Scott Holtzman is tied to a Holtzman Construction LLC in California whose license still shows as active on the Contractors State License Board site.
Customers pressed him directly. One said the company cashed a check while it hadn't talked to Pinal County about the customer's permit for months. Another asked why the company took a large deposit for a disabled veteran's project. Holtzman answered that the company "had ran into difficulties, and it was unexpected."
FOX 10 reported that the Arizona Attorney General's Criminal Division is reviewing consumer complaints. The office hasn't said publicly whether it opened an investigation.
What Arizona law gives homeowners, and what it doesn't
The Recovery Fund has hard caps. Arizona's Residential Contractors' Recovery Fund pays eligible homeowners up to $30,000 per residence, according to the ROC. Under A.R.S. § 32-1139(A), the fund's liability can't exceed $200,000 for any one residential contractor's license. If claims go over that, they're paid pro rata. ROC Director Tom Cole cited both caps to FOX 10. Arizona's Family reported the fund held about $28 million.
Our arithmetic: seven homeowners each awarded the $30,000 maximum would exceed the $200,000 cap on a single license. The Finleys alone reported a gap of roughly $487,000 between what they paid and the work done.
Eligibility is narrow. Under A.R.S. § 32-1132(B), eligible claimants are owner-occupants and certain LLCs, trusts, associations and lessees. The ROC says the fund "does not accept claims from suppliers, subcontractors, laborers or other commercial entities." A commercial owner like Thongtrangan, building a medical office, falls outside it.
Order of operations. For an administrative claim, the ROC says the homeowner must first file a claim against the contractor's license bond and get a final determination. The license also has to be suspended or revoked as a result of that homeowner's complaint (A.R.S. § 32-1133.01). That raises a question for licenses that were voluntarily canceled. Arizona law answers part of it: under A.R.S. § 32-1154(D), a voluntary surrender "does not deprive the registrar of jurisdiction" to investigate or discipline. The ROC also says a contractor's bankruptcy generally doesn't stop it from authorizing a payout to an eligible homeowner. "The important thing is to get that complaint filed as soon as possible," Cole told FOX 10.
Clocks run. The ROC lists two-year limits: for civil Recovery Fund suits (A.R.S. § 32-1133(A)), for administrative claims after the ROC's final order, and for suits on license bonds.
What subcontractors can and can't do
For unpaid trades, Cole told FOX 10 that the remedy "may need to be through the courts." Arizona's lien statute sets the limits:
- Owner-occupied homes are mostly off-limits. Under A.R.S. § 33-1002(B), no lien can be recorded against the dwelling of an owner-occupant except by someone who signed a written contract directly with that owner-occupant. A sub that contracted with the GC generally can't lien the house.
- Commercial jobs are different. That's why Thongtrangan told FOX 10 she worried about subcontractor liens on her project. Under A.R.S. § 33-993(A), a lien claimant has to record within 120 days after completion, or 60 days after a recorded notice of completion. The claim has to show when the preliminary 20-day notice was given.
The lessons for contractors who aren't going under
- Commission without a margin check is a liability. Both the bankruptcy lawyer and the owner described bids that looked profitable in the company's system and weren't. Put a second set of eyes on any bid above a set size before it's signed.
- Progress payments should match progress. Collecting draws on jobs you know you can't finish is exactly what customers raised at the hearing. Tie every draw to completed work, and hand over lien releases as you go.
- Who's named on the license matters. Under A.R.S. § 32-1154(A)(20), having a person named on your license who is or was named on a suspended or revoked license elsewhere is itself grounds for discipline. Under § 32-1154(A)(18), a licensee has 15 days to notify the ROC when the person who qualified the license leaves, and 60 days to qualify through someone else.
That last rule is where qualifiers come in. A licensed qualifying party's name goes on the license, so vetting the business before you accept a role protects your own record. If your business needs a licensed qualifier, or you hold a license that could qualify one, IQS connects the two.
This article is for general information and isn't legal advice. Verify current requirements with your state licensing board or a licensed attorney.
IQS — connecting construction businesses with state-licensed qualifiers.
Sources
- FOX 10 Phoenix: Holtzman Construction bankruptcy: Owner questioned by clients under oath (Nov. 9, 2026)
- FOX 10 Phoenix: Homeowners, subcontractors speak out after Holtzman Construction abruptly pulls license (Sept. 29, 2026)
- FOX 10 Phoenix: Holtzman Construction owner tied to new LLC as customers seek answers (Sept. 30, 2026)
- Arizona's Family: Homeowners face millions in unfinished projects as Tempe contractor declares bankruptcy (Oct. 6, 2026)
- Hard Hat Report: Holtzman Construction owner blames staff for unfinished jobs at Chapter 7 bankruptcy hearing (Nov. 10, 2026)
- Arizona Registrar of Contractors: Recovery Fund
- A.R.S. § 32-1132 · § 32-1139 · § 32-1154
- A.R.S. § 33-1002 · § 33-993
Share this article
Need a licensed qualifier for your business? Request a qualifier match. Hold a license and want to qualify a company? Start here.
Follow International Qualifier Search for more on Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Instagram.
